Legal Alerts Banner 2600x660 1

Is Privilege Worth Fighting Over? Part I 

Lawyers diligently representing their clients usually look for every opportunity to assert and defend a privilege assertion. But in some situations, it may not be worth the effort and expense.

In Dawes v. Newton, S.D.N.Y. Magistrate Judge Robyn Tarnifsky assessed defendants’ privilege and work product claims for what she described as “an unremarkable example” of a joint defense agreement between defendants and third-party witnesses. No. 26-CV-02145 (AT) (RFT), 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 206441, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 9, 2026). After quoting another court’s observation that the privilege case law on that issue is “quite frankly, all over the lot,” the court: denied privilege protection; upheld work product protection; and gave plaintiff only two days to file a letter seeking to overcome the latter protection. Id. at *1-2 (citation omitted).

The existence of a joint defense (common interest) agreement might be significant, but the boilerplate language itself rarely draws a court’s attention – and thus might not be worth defending. Next week’s Privilege Point describes another decision issued five days later – involving another type of document whose existence might be important, but whose content normally is not – litigation holds. 

Subscribe