Key Takeaways
- The amended Fair Chance Act (FCA) rules, which took effect on Oct. 30, 2026, largely implement the 2021 amendments and incorporate existing New York City Commission on Human Rights guidance.
- The rules list per se violations — including pre-offer forms that mention criminal history, even with a disclaimer — that create liability even if no adverse action occurs.
- The rules confirm that applicants and employees have at least five business days to respond to a Fair Chance Employment Notice, and employers with 50 or fewer employees no longer have the early resolution option.
- Employers should review applications, job postings, background check sequencing and Fair Chance notices and should train everyone involved in hiring on the amended rules’ requirements.
Amended rules implementing New York City’s Fair Chance Act (FCA) took effect on Oct. 30, 2026. Approved by the New York City Commission on Human Rights on Sept. 15, 2026, the rules turn the FCA’s 2021 statutory expansions and the Commission’s prior guidance into binding regulations. In doing so, they strengthen protections for applicants and employees and increase employers’ compliance burden by prescribing in greater detail what employers must do, and when, before relying on criminal history.
Background
The FCA, part of the New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL), generally applies to employers with four or more employees, including certain independent contractors, at least one of whom works in New York City. With limited exceptions, it bars employers from asking about or considering a job applicant’s criminal history before making a conditional offer of employment. Before taking adverse action (such as revoking a job offer) based on criminal history, an employer must assess the relevance of the criminal history to the job, give written notice and allow the applicant a chance to respond.
Local Law 4 of 2021 extended these protections to current employees, reached pending cases and more types of criminal history, and limited the reasons an employer may withdraw a “conditional offer.” The Commission proposed conforming rules in July 2024.
Violations of the FCA are subject to the NYCHRL’s remedies. After a finding of liability, the Commission may award back pay, front pay, compensatory damages, attorneys’ fees and other affirmative relief to the individual. It may also impose civil penalties payable to the city of up to $125,000, or up to $250,000 in the case of willful, wanton or malicious conduct. Alternatively, individuals may sue in court, where compensatory and punitive damages, injunctive relief and attorneys’ fees are available.
What the Amended Rules Do
Fair Chance Employment Process. Before acting on criminal history, an employer must ask the individual for relevant information and complete a written Fair Chance Employment Analysis under the applicable factors, including the job’s duties, the bearing of the offense on the individual’s fitness for the job, the seriousness of the offense, the individual’s age at the time of the offense, evidence of rehabilitation and good conduct, the employer’s legitimate interest in protecting property and safety, and the city’s public policy favoring the employment of individuals with criminal records. An employer may take adverse action only if the record has a direct relationship to the job or poses an unreasonable risk. The employer must then give the individual the criminal history relied on, a copy of the analysis and at least five business days to respond, during which it may not permanently fill the position.
Per se violations. The rules expand the list of conduct that violates the FCA on its own, such as asking about criminal history, searching for it or using forms that mention it before a conditional offer (even with a disclaimer, unless another law requires the language), and skipping required notice, response or reanalysis steps. Because no adverse action is required, a single noncompliant application or job posting exposes an employer to the full range of NYCHRL remedies, even if its hiring decision was sound. Employers may, however, encourage people with criminal records to apply and answer applicants who ask whether they run background checks.
Conditional offers. The rules’ definition of “conditional offer” now states that once an employer makes a conditional offer of employment, promotion or transfer, it may withdraw the offer for one of only three reasons: (1) the results of a criminal background check conducted in accordance with the NYCHRL; (2) the results of a medical examination permitted by the Americans with Disabilities Act; or (3) information the employer could not reasonably have known before making the offer and that would have led it not to make the offer, regardless of the background check. In practice, employers must finish all noncriminal screening before making the offer.
Criminal history. “Criminal history” is defined to include conviction history, nonconvictions and pending cases. An adjournment in contemplation of dismissal is a nonconviction unless it is revoked and the case restored before the employer’s analysis.
Misrepresentations. Before acting on an employee or applicant’s alleged intentional misrepresentation of criminal history, the employer must share with the employee or applicant its supporting information, allow at least five business days to respond and consider the response. A mismatch between a background report and self-reported history does not by itself prove dishonesty, and an employer may not act on an individual’s failure to disclose information it was prohibited from asking about. This is a separate, shorter process than the full Fair Chance Employment Process. However, if the response shows that the background check is wrong, the employer must conduct a new Fair Chance Employment Analysis based on the correct history before taking adverse action.
Current employees. While conducting the Fair Chance Employment Process for an employee’s pending case or a conviction that occurs during employment, an employer may place the employee on paid or unpaid leave for a reasonable time. There is a rebuttable presumption that a reasonable time does not exceed five business days. Leave during the process is not in itself an adverse employment action, but leave beyond a reasonable time could be. Once the process is complete, the employer may take adverse action, such as continued suspension or termination, if the direct relationship or unreasonable risk exception applies.
Exemptions. Exemptions are construed narrowly, and the employer must prove that one applies to each action. A law requiring a background check permits a pre-offer check, but unless that law also requires rejection, the employer must still complete the Fair Chance Employment Process before taking adverse action. Job ads generally may not say a background check is required unless another law requires it.
Enforcement. The rules end the early resolution process, under which the Commission could allow eligible employers with 50 or fewer employees to resolve Commission-initiated complaints by admitting liability and paying a set penalty.
Practical Steps for Employers
Audit hiring materials and sequencing. Remove criminal history questions and background check statements from pre-offer materials unless another law requires them. Confirm that noncriminal screening ends before the offer, and that criminal history searches, including online searches, begin only after it.
Update notices and procedures. Reflect the five-business-day minimum, when it starts, the bar on filling the position, review of the individual’s response and written notice of the final decision. Require a new analysis when an individual identifies a material error, and do not treat discrepancies as proof of dishonesty.
Revisit employee and exempt-position practices. Check how pending cases and convictions arising during employment are handled, including leave beyond five business days, and confirm that each exempt position rests on a law that actually requires the check or action.
Train hiring personnel. Recruiters, interviewers, hiring managers, HR staff and screening teams should know the limits on pre-offer questions, including spoken ones, and the direct relationship, unreasonable risk and misrepresentation standards.
McGuireWoods continues to monitor developments in this area. For questions about the amended rules or background check compliance, contact the authors, your McGuireWoods contact, or a member of the firm’s Labor and Employment team.